Skip to main
The Bay Cafe
  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Soups
  • From The Garden
  • Pasta
  • Panini and Wraps
  • Pizza
  • Fish
  • Side Dishes
  • Dessert
  • Crafted Curated Sips
  • Hot Drinks
  • Beverages To Go
  • Breakfast 10am - 1pm
  • Catering Menu - Fish
  • Catering Menu - Pasta
  • Catering Menu - Salad
  • Catering Menu - Appetizers

The Bay Cafe Menu

2 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY

2 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY

·

  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Appetizers
  • Soups
  • From The Garden
  • Pasta
  • Panini and Wraps
  • Pizza
  • Fish
  • Side Dishes
  • Dessert
  • Crafted Curated Sips
  • Hot Drinks
  • Beverages To Go
  • Breakfast 10am - 1pm
  • Catering Menu - Fish
  • Catering Menu - Pasta
  • Catering Menu - Salad
  • Catering Menu - Appetizers

Popular

  • Tiradito De Tuna.

    Tiradito De Tuna

    $29.00

  • Mozzarella Sticks.

    Mozzarella Sticks

    $19.00

  • Hot chocolate.

    Hot chocolate

    $5.45+

  • Crispy Halloumi Salad.

    Crispy Halloumi Salad

    $27.00

  • Apple Crumb.

    Apple Crumb

    $21.00

  • PORCINI MUSHROOM SEA BASS.

    PORCINI MUSHROOM SEA BASS

    $64.00


Appetizers

Crispy Tempura Sea Bass

This delicious fish appetizer has a mild flavor with a subtle sweetness, the flesh is moist and tender and a crunchy tempura coating. Tossed in a sweet & spicy chili sauce.

$29.00

Crispy Tempura Sea Bass.

Arancini

Arancini are crispy risotto balls with a cheesy center - Served with a tomato basil pink sauce

$22.00

Arancini.

Fish Tacos

3 Soft corn tortillas filled w/ Crispy Fried Cod, Slaw & Avocado Mango Salsa

$24.00

Fish Tacos.

Pao De Queijo

This traditional gluten free Brazilian cheese bread is the perfect appetizer for any cheese lover. Crunchy on the outside, soft & chewy inside. Never fried always baked

$21.00

Pao De Queijo.

Mozzarella Sticks

Breaded & Seasoned Mozzarella Fried Golden served w/ Marinara Sauce

$19.00

Mozzarella Sticks.

Cauliflower Poppers

Breaded cauliflower florets served w/ BBQ Sauce

$23.00

Cauliflower Poppers.

Truffle Fries with Parmesan

$18.00

Truffle Fries with Parmesan.

Mac and Cheese

Mornay Sauce, Muenster, Cheddar, Parmesan

$19.00

Mac and Cheese.

Broccoli Cheese Baked Potato

Baked stuffed potatoes, also known as twice-baked potatoes. These jumbo potatoes are baked then scooped out of their skin, mashed, mixed with Broccoli, spooned back into their shell, and topped with mozzarella cheese.

$22.00

Broccoli Cheese Baked Potato.

Dirty Nachos

$28.00

Dirty Nachos.

Tiradito De Tuna

$29.00

Tiradito De Tuna.

Baked Mushroom With Cheese

$19.00

Baked Mushroom With Cheese.

Salmon tacos

$25.00


Soups

French Onion Soup

French Onion Soup with Cheese

$18.00

French Onion Soup.

Butternut Squash

Delicious and healthy creamy squash soup.

$21.00

Butternut Squash.

Split Pea Soup

$13.00

Vegetable Soup

$14.00

Vegetable Soup.

From The Garden

Chop-Chop Bay Salad

Romaine, tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, red bell pepper, parsley, za’atar, breadcrumbs, feta, fresh lemon, extra virgin olive oil

$24.00

Chop-Chop Bay Salad.

Greek Salad

Beef Steak Tomatoes, Peppers, Red Onion, Kalamata Olives, Feta and Greek Dressing

$27.00

Greek Salad.

Caesar Salad

Crispy romaine lettuce, house made croutons, parmesan cheese, gently tossed with our classic Caesar dressing.

$23.00

Caesar Salad.

Asian Chopped Salad

This sweet & savory winter salad is a delicious start to any meal. Roasted red and golden beets, sliced pears, toasted walnuts, feta, mixed greens & quinoa.

$27.00

Asian Chopped Salad.

Mozzarella Caprese

$25.00

Mozzarella Caprese.

Beet Carpaccio

$24.00

Beet Carpaccio.

Roasted Beet and Quinoa Salad

$25.00

Roasted Beet and Quinoa Salad.

Crispy Halloumi Salad

Mixed Greens, Romaine, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumber, Mushroom and Caramelized Onions.

$27.00

Crispy Halloumi Salad.

Spinach apple salad

$24.00


Pasta

Penne Ala Vodka

Penne pasta served with our homemade tomato cream sauce & fresh basil

$29.00

Penne Ala Vodka.

Fettuccini Alfredo with Mushrooms

House made Fettuccini pasta, creamy wild mushroom alfredo sauce (add smoked salmon $6)

$29.00

Fettuccini Alfredo with Mushrooms.

Hand Rolled Cannelloni

Spinach & ricotta rolled into Bay Cafes handmade fresh pasta sheets- topped with parmesan & mozzarella & baked to perfection – served with bechamel & a tomato basil sauce

$34.00

Hand Rolled Cannelloni.

Eggplant Parmesan

Thin slices of fresh eggplant breaded, baked with our homemade marinara sauce, & topped with mozzarella & parmesan. Served over spaghetti.

$29.00

Eggplant Parmesan.

Gnocchi

In house made potato gnocchi with pesto, alfredo, or vodka sauce

$36.00

Gnocchi.

Spaghetti Pomodoro

Penne pasta with our signature marinara sauce

$27.00

Spaghetti Pomodoro.

Spaghetti Squash Medley

Gluten Free, Spaghetti Squash served with feta cheese, sautéed vegetables, olives & basil.

$27.00

Spaghetti Squash Medley.

Papa Pasta with Broccoli

$30.00

Wild Mushroom Risotto

Authentic Italian Style Risotto with Mushrooms, Topped with Parmesan. Gluten Free

$27.00

Wild Mushroom Risotto.

Panini and Wraps

Avocado

Avocado, Hard Egg, Feta, Lettuce, Olive Tapenade, Tomato.

$20.00

Avocado.

Mozzarella

Fresh Mozzarella, Avocado, Tomato, Creamy Pesto Sauce.

$20.00

Mozzarella.

Tuna Melt

Tuna Salad, Mozzarella Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onions.

$20.00

Tuna Melt.

Pizza

American Pizza

$24.00

American Pizza.

Margherita Pizza

Tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese & Basil

$26.00

Margherita Pizza.

Olive Zaatar Pizza

Mozzarella, olives, zaatar & sesame (no sauce)

$25.00

Olive Zaatar Pizza.

Pizza Bianca

This delicious White Pizza is drizzled with olive oil, garlic, and white cheeses

$25.00

Pizza Bianca.

Truffle Mushroom Pizza

Seasoned with fresh truffle zest and mushrooms.

$26.00

Truffle Mushroom Pizza.

Adjarian Khachapuri

Authentic Georgian style cheese bread. It's an open-faced, boat-shaped loaf that’s served with a soft baked egg and a slice of butter.

$28.00

Adjarian Khachapuri.

Fish

CEDAR PLANK SALMON

You will get that lovely smoky flavor from the cedar wood in this select cut salmon. Comes with Grilled Vegetables and Organic WIld Rice. The maple and ginger are the perfect complement to this recipe.

$46.00

CEDAR PLANK SALMON.

OVEN ROASTED SALMON

Fresh fillet salmon, seasoned with salt & pepper baked to perfection. Comes with Sauteed Broccoli and Mashed Potatoes.

$46.00

OVEN ROASTED SALMON.

THE QUEENS FISH ‘N’ CHIPS

Fresh fillet of white fish, coated in our signature batter, gently fried to the perfect crispness & accompanied by fresh cut russet potato fries – served with malt vinegar & tartar sauce.

$44.00

THE QUEENS FISH ‘N’ CHIPS.

MEDITERRANEAN BRANZINO

Simply … healthy & delicious. ** Whole Fish Butterfly Fillet, Baked with Oregano and Lemon. Comes with Sauteed Broccoli and Roasted Baby Potatoes.

$49.00

MEDITERRANEAN BRANZINO.

PAN SEARED BRANZINO

2 Fillets of Branzino are gently pan seared and seasoned. Comes with Roasted Baby Potatoes and Sauteed Spinach.

$48.00

PAN SEARED BRANZINO.

PORCINI MUSHROOM SEA BASS

This amazing Wild Catch Chilean Sea Bass is perfectly buttery and delicious. It is served with mediterranean salsa verde on top. Comes with Organic Wild Rice and Grilled Vegetables.

$64.00

PORCINI MUSHROOM SEA BASS.

WALNUT CRUST TURBOT

Perfectly flaky & buttery with Walnuts crust, served with Grilled Vegetables, Mashed Potatoes.

$46.00

WALNUT CRUST TURBOT.

Side Dishes

SAUTEED BROCCOLI

$14.00

SAUTEED BROCCOLI.

FRENCH FRIES

$14.00

GRILLED VEGETABLES

$14.00

GRILLED VEGETABLES.

ORGANIC WILD RICE

$14.00

MASHED POTATOES

$14.00

SAUTEED SPINACH

$14.00

SAUTEED SPINACH.

ROASTED BABY POTATO

$14.00

ROASTED BABY POTATO.

Dessert

Chocolate Souffle

This classic dessert is airy, with a deep chocolate flavor with a decadent chocolate center served warm with a scoop of ice cream

$19.00

Chocolate Souffle.

Old Fashion Cheesecake

Our famous creamy cheesecake with a graham cracker crust

$21.00

Old Fashion Cheesecake.

Churros

There’s nothing like a fresh homemade churro. Crispy on the outside, soft & tender on the inside comes with a chocolate hazelnut ganache dipping sauce.

$18.00

Churros.

Lemon Curd Cheesecake

This dessert is prepared in a cup with the bottom layer of graham crust, center filled with the rich & buttery texture of the most delicious Mascarpone cheesecake and topped off with the perfect silky smooth tangy sweet Lemon Curd

$19.00

Lemon Curd Cheesecake.

Belgian Waffles

Fresh baked Belgian waffles with ice cream, whipped cream, candy sprinkles berries & bananas

$18.00

Belgian Waffles.

Creme Brulee

The smooth and creamy texture of this sweet custard is highlighted by its candied top – always a delicious classic. Gluten Free.

$20.00

Creme Brulee.

Apple Crumb

A delicious blend of fuji and granny smith apples cinnamon & a touch of nutmeg bring this dessert to a whole new level. Served with a scoop of ice cream - vanilla, chocolate, strawberry or coffee

$21.00

Apple Crumb.

Ice Cream Scoop

Vanilla, Strawberry, Chocolate, Coffee Price per scoop

$4.00

Ice Cream Scoop.

Dubai Chocolate

Milk chocolate, Pistachio Cream, and Kataifi, a Crunchy Fried Phyllo Dough.

$18.00

Dubai Chocolate.

Sachlav

Milk Pudding Garnish, Cinamon, Pistachio

$15.00

Sachlav.

Affogato

Vanilla Ice Cream topped with a shot of espresso.

$14.00

Tiramisu

$21.00


Crafted Curated Sips

Iced Coffee

$5.00

Cold Brew

$8.00

Iced Latte

$8.00

Iced Cappuccino

$8.00

Classic Frappes

$10.00

Mocha Cookie Frappuccino

$10.00

Mix Frappuccino

$10.00

LimoNana Thrill

$13.00

Ice tea

$4.00

Smoothie

$12.00

Matcha Latte Iced

$10.00

MILK SHAKE

$10.00

Pina Colada Splash V

$13.00

Strawberry Daiquiri V

$13.00

Fresh Brewed Ice Tea Pitcher

$12.00

Dragonfruit Specialty

$13.00

Hibiscus Boba Tea

$12.00

Blackforest Boba Tea

$12.00

Matcha Delight Boba Tea

$13.00

Passion Fruit Bliss

$13.00

Lemonana A

$16.00

Orange juice

$8.00

Watermelon Mojito

$12.00


Hot Drinks

Cappuccino

Espresso, steamed milk topped with milk froth & cinnamon

$5.45+

Cappuccino.

Americano

Shot of espresso with hot water

$4.45+

Cafe Latte

Espresso & steamed milk

$5.45+

Hot coffe

$3.50+

Espresso

$3.50+

Caramel Macchiato

$5.95+

Mocha Latte

Espresso, steamed milk & chocolate

$5.95+

Nana tea

Fresh Mint with hot water.

$4.00

Hot Tea

$2.75+

Hazelnut Latte

$5.95+

Almond Milk Latte

$8.00

Vanilla Latte

Shot of espresso, steamed milk, French vanilla

$5.95+

Matchta Latte Hot

$10.00

Hot chocolate

A warming and comforting cup of our decadent hot chocolate

$5.45+

Hot chocolate.

Honey Almond Milk Latte

Shot of espresso, almond milk, and a touch of honey

$5.95+

Macchiato

Shot of espresso topped with steamed milk

$4.95+

Small tea

$7.00

Medium tea

$12.00

Large tea

$18.00

Apple Cider

$10.00

Turkish Coffee

$6.00


Beverages To Go

Ice coffee

$5.00

Water

$2.50

Soda

$3.50

Snapple

$3.75


Breakfast 10am - 1pm

Omelette Special

$24.00

Eggs Any Style

$16.00

Cheese Omelette

$20.00

Scrambled Eggs & Lox

$25.00

Vegetable Omelette

$20.00

Florentine Omelette

$22.00

Shakshuka

$25.00

Breakfast Belgian Waffles

$15.00

Pancakes

$15.00

Challah French Toast

$18.00

Avocado Toast

$21.00


Catering Menu - Fish

Grilled Vegetables

$70.00

Grilled Vegetables.

Roasted Baby Potatoes

$65.00

Organic Wild Rice

$65.00


Catering Menu - Pasta

Penne Vodka Catering Tray

Penne pasta served with our homemade tomato cream sauce & fresh basil. Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.

$135.00+

Penne Vodka Catering Tray.

Eggplant Parmesan Catering Tray

Thin slices of fresh eggplant breaded, baked with our homemade marinara sauce, & topped with mozzarella & parmesan. Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.

$140.00+

Eggplant Parmesan Catering Tray.

Fettuccini Alfredo with mushroom Catering Tray

Fettuccini pasta served with our creamy alfredo sauce Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.

$135.00+

Fettuccini Alfredo with mushroom Catering Tray.

Mac & Cheese Catering Tray

Considered the queen of comfort food, our Mac & Cheese includes a selected types of cheeses to bring you the most delightful cheesy pasta experience. Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.

$139.00+

Mac & Cheese Catering Tray.

Pasta Marinara Catering Tray

Penne pasta with our signature marinara sauce Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.

$119.00+

Pasta Marinara Catering Tray.

Spaghetti Pomodoro

$60.00

Spaghetti Pomodoro.

Gnocchi

$80.00

Gnocchi.

Catering Menu - Salad

Halloumi Salad

$70.00

Avocado Salad

$65.00

Beet Carpaccio

$65.00

Beet Carpaccio.

Catering Menu - Appetizers

Fish Tacos 20 pcs.

$100.00

Fish Tacos 20 pcs..

Salmon Tacos 20 pcs.

$110.00

Arancini 20pcs

$80.00

Arancini 20pcs.

Fish Tempura

$100.00

The Bay Café
  • Menu

  • Reservations

  • Catering

  • Our Story

  • Events

  • Gift Cards

  • Contact Us

Terms of serviceAccessibility

he Bay Cafe 369 Corp. 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner